Why you should drop your Twitter disclaimer

Share

Twitter disclaimers such as, “Views are my own and don’t reflect the views of my employer,” are a subject that divides opinion.

Some argue that they are an essential safeguard; others say they are meaningless. I’d go further and argue that for PR practitioners (and other communications disciplines) such disclaimers are actually dangerous.

The disclaimer provides no protection whatsoever and can engender a false sense of security.

Such disclaimers don’t provide legal protection. If you say something that you shouldn’t, then having that little disclaimer won’t save you from disciplinary action or, if your comments are outrageous enough, from being sacked for gross misconduct.

The same goes for the disclaimer in your Twitter biography that reads, “Retweets don’t imply endorsement or agreement.” You are disseminating information, and if it is libelous or inaccurate, then you can be held accountable.

However it isn’t the legal aspect that makes these disclaimers not just wrong, but potentially dangerous. It’s the practical reality of how most reasonable people will view them—what the man on the Clapham omnibus will think (in UK law a hypothetical reasonable person).

Disclaimers don’t work because:

    1. Many people will never see them. They will just see your tweet or retweet and never click through to your profile to see your biography and disclaimer.

    2. People will inevitably associate what you say and what you do with your employer. This post isn’t about debating the rights and wrongs of this. It’s simply stating that it is the reality.

    For anyone who can be considered the public face of an organization or company this is even truer. If you’re a senior manager or director, a PR practitioner, a politician, a company spokesperson, or something similar, then what you do and say directly affect both your employer’s reputation and your own.

    That means you’ve always got to be careful what you say.

    If companies or organizations really want to protect themselves from reputational damage from what their employees say on social media, then a far better solution than disclaimers is to implement proper social media policies and training. A good social media policy will make it easier for employees to use social media safely, ultimately protecting both the employee and the employer.

    [RELATED: Ragan’s new distance-learning site houses the most comprehensive video training library for corporate communicators.]

    There are countless examples of senior PR people, both in-house and at agencies, who tweet extensively without the need for disclaimers. A few friends and acquaintances who correctly don’t use disclaimers include:

    • Flip Dotsch, global corporate media relations, Unilever
    • Tom Murphy, global director of communications for Windows at Microsoft Corporation
    • Dom Burch, head of social, Walmart UK (Asda)
    • David Brain, CEO Asia/Pacific/Middle East/Africa, Edelman
    • Stephen Waddington, digital and social media director, Ketchum and 2014 president of the CIPR
    • Stephen Davies, director of digital health Europe, Weber Shandwick

    All these in-house and PR agency experts have excellent Twitter accounts that mix the personal with the professional.

    I’ll give the last word to Tom Murphy who wrote a far pithier post on Twitter disclaimers.

    Footnote (and my own disclaimer)

    The current guidance from the Chartered Institute of Public Relations (to be fully transparent I’m a founder member of and sit on the CIPR’s Social Media Panel which produced these guidelines) in its Social Media Best Practice Guide fudges the issue and says:

    For example, it can be advisable to add a “views are my own” disclaimer to a Twitter biography, if a practitioner tweets about client and industry related news / opinions, [professional] and also shares their personal views on a subject that lies outside of their work remit [personal], through the same Twitter account.

    However, practitioners should be aware that this will not remove the risk of association with an employer, potentially damaging their reputation, and that adding this to a profile has no legal standing in the UK.

    Stuart Bruce is a UK-based international PR adviser and trainer. A version of this article first appeared on Stuart Bruce’s PR Guy’s Musings. 

    Popularity: This record has been viewed 2253 times.
    Ragan.com moderates comments and reserves the right to remove posts that are abusive or otherwise inappropriate.

    Ragan.com

    Share

    Why Your Twitter Disclaimer Does More Harm Than Good

    Share

    bigstock-Disclaimer-the-Dictionary-Pro-18198233 If I’ve seen it once, I’ve seen it a thousand times:

    My tweets do not represent the opinion of my employer.

    Is it just me, or is this the most ridiculous statement ever? Every time I see it, I get twitchy. Because it anything, you’re making things worse.

    People think that this disclaimer justifies bad behavior on Twitter. Or rather, not bad per se, but behavior not in line with their employer’s brand. They curse, make lewd comments, start drama, or otherwise act in controversial ways, then they point to their disclaimer and say, “But it’s okay, because this is me and I’m not representing a brand right now.”

    Why is this ridiculous?

    Let’s say you see someone out at the bar, getting wasted, hitting on everything with a pulse, and yelling racial slurs in a drunken stupor. Then, the next day, you see that same person working at Disney World. You’d probably be pretty disgusted that a company like Disney would work with someone like that.

    Would it make a difference if, the night before at the bar, the person was wearing a shirt with “Anything I’m doing right now doesn’t represent my employer, Disney!” printed on it? Absolutely not. If anything, it draws attention to the juxtaposition between the idiot behavior and the family-friendly employee.

    Here’s the thing: anything you do or say online represents your employer, whether you post a disclaimer or not.

    If you want to publicly post pictures of you doing shots at the bar, make sure that it isn’t going to hurt your employer’s brand. Some companies are more family-friendly than others. If your personality doesn’t fit well with your company’s brand, it is probably time to start looking for a new job.

    It makes me wrinkle my nose when I hear about companies trying to control their employees’ social accounts, but remember: How you represent yourself online can affect whether or not you get a raise, whether or not you survive a round of layoffs, and whether or not you are promoted into a leadership position. It’s not about your employer controlling your social accounts. It’s about respect, and realizing that your actions online are as real as your actions in a face-to-face situation.

    So stop it with the disclaimers. They don’t mean anything. Just act responsibly online, and don’t write anything on Twitter that you wouldn’t send to your boss directly.

    Image Credit: Bigstock

    Join us in Las Vegas at our biggest event ever! REGISTER TODAY for best savings on your pass! Want to learn how to create better content for your Blog, Podcast or Video Series from the most successful content creators? What about growing your audience or monetizing in smart, sustainable ways? How about leveraging social media marketing to grow your brand, sales and community? Come network with peers and most importantly, find the solutions you need at the world’s largest conference and trade show for the new media industry, New Media Expo! Reserve your seat at the best price now!
    Be Sociable, Share!

    New Media Expo Blog

    Share