Google’s advisory committee recommends “right to be forgotten” never comes to America



A Google committee has recommended that the “right to be forgotten” be restricted to Europe.

At issue is the claim that search results removed via the ruling should also be removed from search results around the world because — get this — Europeans can use global websites.

Google has often complained about the ruling, which went into effect in May 2014, because it believes removing items from its search results impedes the free flow of information.

So it set up this committee, which only has the ability to make recommendations and is not able to influence either Google’s policies or European governments.

Among the committee’s members are Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales, who has criticized the “right to be forgotten” ruling since it was first revealed. As he writes in this new report:

“I completely oppose the legal situation in which a commercial company is forced to become the judge of our most fundamental rights of expression and privacy. The recommendations to Google contained in this report are deeply flawed due to the law itself being deeply flawed.”

Besides setting up this committee, Google has also taken the fight directly to regulators, attempting to get the press on its side by informing it of erroneously-removed links.

Yet nobody in Europe is backing down from the “right to be forgotten” ruling. Indeed, regulators have imposed even more guidelines and requirements on search companies affected by the rule:

The data protection authorities in Europe said on Thursday that they will soon require companies like Google, affected by the controversial “right to be forgotten” ruling, to develop “common case-handling criteria,” create a “common record of decisions,” and contribute to a “dashboard to help identify similar cases as well as new or more difficult cases.”

The right to be forgotten appears to be here to stay. Now all Google and the rule’s other detractors can do is hope to contain it — and that’s exactly what this report intends to do.



NFL’s Goodell apologizes and establishes ‘conduct committee,’ but will that satisfy critics?

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell spoke to the press for the first time in 10 days in a Friday afternoon press conference, apologizing for the league’s handling of domestic abuse that made sponsors call for corrective action and fans call for the commissioner’s resignation.

In his statement, Goodell said:

Unfortunately, over the past several weeks, we have seen all too much of the NFL doing wrong. That starts with me. I said this before back on Aug. 28, and I’ll say it again now. I got it wrong in the handling of the Ray Rice matter, and I’m sorry for that. I got it wrong on a number of levels, from the process that I lead, to the decision that I reached. But now I will get it right and do whatever is necessary to accomplish that.

The NFL’s answer

Goodell said action, not just words, are needed in order to answer to recent events. He then announced the following five initiatives:

1. An internal investigation Former FBI director Robert S. Mueller III will oversee an independent investigation into how the league handled the Rice domestic violence situation.

2. A new conduct committee. Goodell announced a new committee that will help set domestic abuse and sexual assault policies within the league.

3. Education, advocacy, and training. The league is currently revamping its education program and NFL personnel will begin participating in education and training sessions regarding domestic abuse and sexual assault within the next month.

4. New partnerships. The NFL has partnered with the National Domestic Violence Hotline and the Sexual Violence Resource Center.

5. New NFL personal conduct policy. The NFL will create a new policy regarding personal conduct in the areas of domestic abuse, sexual assault, firearm possession, and drug and alcohol abuse.

The reaction

Although the initiatives Goodell delivered seemed positive, some reporters and fans said it was too little, too late.

To begin, he didn’t do himself any favors with the robotic way he delivered his statement:

Goodell also earned backlash for avoiding reporters’ questions and being vague:

For many critics, the only acceptable action from Goodell is to step down.

Goodell said he hasn’t considered resigning. He maintained that both he and the league were busy fixing mistakes made, and there is much work to be done.

Many listeners didn’t buy it.

Even NFL players called for Goodell’s resignation, including Myles White, wide receiver for the Green Bay Packers.

Some fans took to making Photoshops of Goodell as Pinnochio and Richard Nixon:

Goodell pledged to make good on his promises when asked what sponsors want.

“They want to see us make that difference, and it’s up to us to deliver on that. They’re not looking for talk. They want to see action.”

And so do the fans, who will hold him to his word and be first to pounce if Goodell falters. 

Popularity: This record has been viewed 71 times. moderates comments and reserves the right to remove posts that are abusive or otherwise inappropriate.